Skip to content

Blog

Adding WPF Upgrade Support for VB.NET Modernization

Abstract
The gmStudio distribution includes a sample demonstrating an upgrade of VB6 forms to WPF. This sample was originally implemented for C#. The purpose of this article is to describe how we added a WPF sample for VB.NET and provide insights into advanced customization. The work required changes to the following metalanguage files:

  • enumerations.xml
  • vbcontrols.xml
  • locSubsystem.gmsl
  • wpfSubsystem.gmsl
  • vb7lang.xml
  • VBASIC.xml

Background
A Subsystem is a collection of related upgrade rules that provide a specific upgrade feature. The current WPF/C# sample uses subsystem=wpf and subsystem=loc (light-weight object oriented C# coding style). The two subsystems are activated by adding two commands to the translation script:

<Select SubSystem="wpf"/>
<Select SubSystem2="loc"/>

Generally speaking, the WPF/VB.NET sample will be analogous to the WPF/C# sample. However, the problems are in the details: I initially find the WPF subsystem contains several C#-specific patterns in vbcontrols.xml; for example, there are int and double casts as well as a few other C# patterns relating to data binding:

<pattern id="Top.Set" >
<wpf narg="2" code="Canvas.SetTop(%2d,(double)(%1d))\c" />
<all narg="2" code="%2d.Top = %1d\c" />
</pattern>

What is needed here is a VB.NET form for some WPF operations. This is analogous to the situation with SubSystem=loc/lob where some patterns need both a VB.NET and a C# form. For WPF we will need a pair of subsystems, wpf/wpb, for C#/VB.NET respectively. The new subsystem is added to enumerations.xml:

<MetaLanguage>
<Enumeration id="Dialects" >
...
<Entry id="wpf" migName="LNG_WPF" value="9" />
<Entry id="loc" migName="LNG_LOC" value="10" />
<Entry id="lob" migName="LNG_LOB" value="11" />
<Entry id="wpb" migName="LNG_WPB" value="12" /> <------ added
</Enumeration>

Returning to vbcontrols.xml, I can add wpb versions of the dailect-specific wpf patterns, for example:

<pattern id="Top.Set" >
<wpb narg="2" code="Canvas.SetTop(%2d,%1d)\c" /> <------ added
<wpf narg="2" code="Canvas.SetTop(%2d,(double)(%1d))\c" />
<all narg="2" code="%2d.Top = %1d\c" />
</pattern>

I find another dialect-specific WPF pattern in VBASIC.XML. This pattern specifies the operation needed to start a WPF application. A VB.NET version is added:

<pattern id="WPO">
<subcode id="SetCanvas">
<wpf narg="3" code="%2d.%3d = %1d\c"/>
<all narg="3" code="Canvas.Set%3d(%2d, %1d)\c"/>
</subcode>
<subcode id="RunProject" >
<wpb narg="4" code="Dim app As New %4d.App : app.Run(%1d)\c" /> <------------ added
<all narg="4" code="new %4d.App().Run(%1d)\c" />
</subcode>
</pattern>

In order to activate the new wpb subsystem, I need to modify the CompilerInfo handlers to include wbp in the Subsystem stack for Dialect=vbn. The CompilerInfo handlers are gmSL routines that are called by the tool when it begins processing the Compile command in a translation script. There is a CompilerInfo handler for Subsystem=loc and I will add one for SubSystem=wpf. The change must be made to load the subsystems in the correct order of precedence based on the selected .NET language dialect.

locSubsystem.gmsl
int locCompilerInfo(int dummy1, int dummy2)
{
if(Select.Dialect == Dialects.vbn)
{
if (Select.SubSystem == Dialects.wpb)
{
Select.Subsystem = Dialects.wpb;
Select.Subsystem2 = Dialects.wpf;
Select.Subsystem3 = Dialects.lob;
Select.Subsystem4 = Dialects.loc;
}
else
{
Select.Subsystem = Dialects.lob;
Select.Subsystem2 = Dialects.loc;
}
}
else
{
if (Select.SubSystem == Dialects.wpf)
{
Select.Subsystem = Dialects.wpf;
Select.Subsystem2 = Dialects.loc;
}
}
return 0;
}
wpfSubsystem.gmsl
int wpfCompilerInfo(int dummy1, int dummy2)
{
if(Select.Dialect == Dialects.vbn)
{
Select.Subsystem = Dialects.wpb;
Select.Subsystem2 = Dialects.wpf;
Select.Subsystem3 = Dialects.lob;
Select.Subsystem4 = Dialects.loc;
}
else
{
Select.Subsystem = Dialects.wpf;
Select.Subsystem2 = Dialects.loc;
}
return 0;
}

There are several places in authortext.gmsl testing for the presence of a subsystems. For these more complex multi-subsystem scenarios, they may also need to check SubSystem2, Subsystem3, etc. authortext.xml must also be modified to allow for this. A utility function, hasSubSystem, will be used to help make these tests in a consistent way.

int hasSubSystem(int theSubSystem)
{
if (Select.SubSystem ==theSubSystem) return 1;
if (Select.SubSystem2==theSubSystem) return 2;
if (Select.SubSystem3==theSubSystem) return 3;
if (Select.SubSystem4==theSubSystem) return 4;
if (Select.SubSystem5==theSubSystem) return 5;
return 0;
}

Several other simple changes relating to default assembly references and Imports statements were needed to support WPF for VBN. These are done by modifying in authortext.gmsl.

A critical part of supporting the WPF upgrade relates to authoring XAML from the VB6 forms and declaring the WPF Application class. This work is done in the wpfSubSystem.gmsl script. This gmSL script contains various upgrade event handlers and supporting routines that are called by gmBasic at the appropriate times during the authoring process. Support for VB.NET was added by making the code in wpfSubSystem.gmsl dialect-specific: adding logic to author either C# or VB.NET code depending on the dialect setting.

Next, I add an entry to VB7Lang.xml so that both the wpf SubSystem and the new wpb SubSystem will invoke the upgrade event handlers implemented in WPFSubsystem.gmsl:

<gmSL NameSpace="gmSL" class="WPFSubSystem" Source="%UserFolder%\WPFSubsystem.gmsl" />
<gmSL NameSpace="gmSL" class="WPBSubSystem" Source="%UserFolder%\WPFSubsystem.gmsl" /> <-------------- added

I need to recompile the Metalanguage using the modified files. This creates a binary metalanguage file that can be used during the translation process.

With these changes, the WPF feature may be activated by adding one line to a translation script:

<Select SubSystem="wpf"/>

The above now works for both Dialect=csh and Dialect=vbn. Note: the WPF upgrade subsystem is a limited implementation: it supports most VB6 intrinsic controls and the COM TabControl (TabDlg). Additional VB6/COM controls and other features may be added by modifying the appropriate language scripts and COM description files. Contact us if you have any questions.


gmStudio Release News: March 2017 Updates

New gmStudio Case Studies and Testimonials

Section titled “New gmStudio Case Studies and Testimonials”

A handful of recent customers allowed us to publish brief descriptions of their VB6/COM upgrade projects and their testimonials of success with gmStudio. Learn how small teams successfully completed large, ambitious VB6/COM upgrade efforts with the help of gmStudio. Read the case studies

The gmStudio distribution includes a sample demonstrating an upgrade of VB6 forms to WPF. This sample was originally implemented for C# only. In this release, we added a WPF sample for VB.NET and published a blog article to describe how we did it.

gmBasic is a powerful code processor that reads, interprets, and rewrites VB6/ASP/COM systems as .NET (C# or VB.NET). We are always improving gmBasic so that it is more robust and flexible and it produces cleaner, more correct results. This distribution, Version 30.44, includes several enhancements:

  • Improves the general, right out-of-the-box, ability to produce build-complete .NET code from very large, very complex VB6 systems (most recently including enhancements needed to upgrade a Comprehensive Tax Preparation of 19 inter-related VBPs referencing 993 unique files containing over 1.4M unique LOC and 42 third party COM components)
  • Improves rewriting complex GoSub blocks as separate functions
  • Improves handling undeclared variables
  • Improves rewriting complex conditional expressions that mix booleans and enums
  • Improves relocating local Const variables when needed to initialize local Static arrays
  • Improves rewriting Select/Case statements
  • Improves rewriting designer code enum properties initialized with an undefined numeric values
  • Improves rewriting IIf with incompatible true/false result types
  • Improves determining if a control or its default property is needed when referenced from outside the host form
  • Improves rewriting large numeric literal expressions to prevent compile-time overflow
  • Improves identifying collection properties and migrating complex references to collection element
  • Improves rewriting binary operations involving decimal and DateTime quantities
  • Improves rewriting logic for control arrays as logic using SortedList
  • Improves handling files that had internal naming collision
  • Improves rewriting the Unload control statement
  • Improves rewriting references to the Index property of control arrays.
  • Improves propagating custom interface events to Implementing classes
  • Improves rewriting very large numeric consts that were specified as string literals
  • Improves inferring and propagating the rank and marshalling of array parameters
  • Improves placement of temporary variables created in nested code blocks
  • Improves type inference for collections of collections
  • Improves rewriting Friend interface members as public
  • Improves rewriting parameterized properties

gmStudio: Upgrade Solution Development Environment Update

Section titled “gmStudio: Upgrade Solution Development Environment Update”

Powered by gmBasic, gmStudio is a development environment for creating high-performance, custom VB6/ASP/COM to .NET upgrade solutions. We are always adding functionality to gmStudio and also making it easier to use. This distribution includes several enhancements:

  • Adds support for Side-by-Side Code Viewer with ASP upgrade projects
  • Adds support for creating new gmStudio projects from the command line interface
  • Improves default results folder naming conventions to use a simpler, more natural form
  • Improves Close Project behavior
  • Improves error handling and reporting for Meta-Language and Translation processes
  • Adds Double-Click to Edit User-Files on the Configuration form
  • Improves Edit Project Name behavior on the Configuration form
  • Improves the Search Reporting for XML files in the User and System folder by reporting fully qualified location of matches.
  • Improves default Search List/Reporting layout when their orientation changes
  • Improves Visual Studio Solution Generator to set stable project GUIDs based on upgrade project task names
  • Corrects Task order displayed on the Upgrade Wizard to reflect build order and processing order
  • Corrects new projects to suppress upgrading Collections/Dictionaries to strongly-typed Generic collections

gmStudio ships with a collection of sample upgrade rules that can be used to add custom features to your upgrade solution. These XML documents and gmSL scripts are distributed as source that you may modify to fit your unique requirements. The latest distribution of sample rules files includes several improvements:

  • Adds scripts showing how VB6 forms may be upgraded to WPF/XAML for VB.NET. Formerly this was only available for C#

Great Migrations publishes a number of sample VB6/ASP upgrade solutions to illustrate the capabilities of gmStudio. The samples were updated to reflect the latest product improvements and conventions.

  • Adds a sample demonstrating VB6 forms to WPF/XAML for VB.NET. Formerly this was only available for C#

Voice of the Customer: Global Success Stories

A number of our recent customers allowed us to publish brief descriptions of their VB6/COM upgrade projects and their testimonials of success with gmStudio. Learn how small teams successfully completed large, ambitious VB6/COM upgrade efforts with the help of gmStudio.

Why Leave VB6/ASP Behind This Year?

:::note Summary

Given the ever-changing nature of requirements, people, and technologies impacting software development, legacy modernization is an inevitable challenge. Learn about why you should boost the urgency of your modernization efforts in this article.

::: If you still are holding off on your migration project, here are a few reasons why it is more urgent need


First, the official end-of-support for Visual Basic classic (VB6) was in April 2008 — almost 15 years ago. It has also been well over 20 years since the last major release of VB6. As a result, the number of skilled developers who are available and willing to work with VB6 is critically low. This represents a growing business risk for organizations maintaining systems in VB6. The same type of risks exist for organizations maintaining web sites with ASP classic. Keep in mind that no one last for ever, if you depend on key people to help you maintain your legacy apps, they are always getting closer to **retirement;**you would do well to complete your modernization projects while they are available to help.

Second, there have been many recent changes for Windows Operating Systems:

  • End of Windows XP Extended Support: April 2014
  • End of Windows Server 2008 Mainstream Support: January 2015
  • Start of Availability of Windows 10: July 2015
  • Start of Availability of Windows Server 2016: October 2016
  • End of Support for Windows 7: January 2020

Third, Microsoft has made huge investments in .NET. Since 2000, Microsoft has published many significant releases of the .NET languages, frameworks, and tools. In addition, Microsoft and others have made great investments in open source. .NET has been well-received by product vendors, developers, and other experts. It enjoys outstanding support from the open source community with compilers, IDEs, frameworks, and other tools enabling .NET development for platforms other than Windows. Going into 2017, we find .NET is a powerful, mature development platform backed by a global community of IT professionals.

Fourth, the last decade brought important advancements in how we build software: improved development operations tools and techniques, powerful new frameworks and design patterns, and exciting new areas for application features. These new tools, new methodologies, work well with .NET. When they are combined with strategic business vision, they make a strong case for modernizing VB6/ASP legacy systems and adopting .NET.

For organizations still running on old, unsupported technologies, this may be the year to plan and implement a successful upgrade! We have the upgrade technology and the necessary expertise in this area to assist you. Please give us a call or email — we will be very happy to hear from you.

gmStudio Version 30.43: Modernization Improvements

gmBasic is a powerful code processor that reads, interprets, and rewrites VB6/ASP/COM systems as .NET (C# or VB.NET). We are always improving gmBasic so that it is more robust and flexible and it produces cleaner, more correct results. This distribution, Version 30.43, includes several enhancements:

  • Improves the general ability to produce build-complete .NET code from very large, very complex VB6 systems (most recently including enhancements needed to upgrade a Comprehensive Accounting System of 38 inter-related VBPs re ferencing 1,149 unique files containing over 1.8M unique LOC).
  • Improves ByRef to ByVal optimization rules
  • Improves precision of division involving fixed-point quantities.
  • Improves handling of international Character sets in source code and upgrade configuration files
  • Improves handling With blocksusing instance of a user-defined type (C#)
  • Improves handling of IsNull/Null operations with default properties
  • Improves handling of power-of-ten numeric constants to use the ‘E’ notation (e.g., 1.0E3)
  • Improves handling of optional parameters that use private symbols as default values by using overloading

gmStudio: Upgrade Solution Development Environment

Section titled “gmStudio: Upgrade Solution Development Environment”

Powered by gmBasic, gmStudio is a development environment for creating high-performance, custom VB6/ASP/COM to .NET upgrade solutions. We are always adding functionality to gmStudio and also making it easier to use. This distribution includes several enhancements:

  • Adds a FileName attribute in the ScriptRule commands
  • Adds support for copying selected text to the clipboard from the Side-by-Side code review form
  • Adds support for authoring ’%’ character from Search Reporting template (useful for generating refactoring commands from search results)
  • Improves copying task list data using CTRL-C (names) and Shift-CTRL-C (details)
  • Adds option to add a User Command Script to each task when adding tasks to a gmStudio project file
  • Improves Search Reporting options: unique, template, detail, none
  • Improves ProgID Report by removing deprecated CLSID field
  • Corrects issue with FileExists test when file path is null
  • Corrects issue with starting application with the /folder command line switch

gmStudio ships with a collection of sample upgrade rules that can be used to add custom features to your upgrade solution. These XML documents and gmSL scripts are distributed as source that you may modify to fit your unique requirements. The latest distribution of sample rules files includes several improvements:

  • Standardizes sample COM replacement rulesso that the internal library id is same as default COM library id. This simplifies activating COM replacement rules files in your upgrade solution
  • Simplifies MigrationSupport namespace conventions to streamline the supporting code if needed
  • Updates standard script templates by moving configuration folder specifications to top of script
  • Updates comments in sample standard script templates standard script templates file

Great Migrations publishes a number of sample VB6/ASP upgrade solutions to illustrate the capabilities of gmStudio. The samples were updated to reflect the latest product improvements and conventions

Download: